Confronting Commercialization of Healthcare 947


Confronting Commercialization of Healthcare

 

Recently I came across an interesting book, “The People’s Health Sourcebook”. Section 5 of this book was of particular interest to me, I have used its title as the title of this article, I am a healthcare architect with by and large corporate clients.

I am encouraged to quote extensively from the book by the authors themselves, they say:
“Any part of this book or the entire book may be copied or translated or used in any way provided it is not used for profit or commercial purposes.”
Well I will get paid a few hundred rupees for this article; I hope the authors will not grudge me that. I would just like to examine their thesis in the light of my experience of working closely with corporate healthcare providers in designing their hospitals. Being an architect and a very visual person myself I am delighted to re-present the very good visuals they use to make their point, the first one of which immediately follows:

bbb1

 

 

The text following this is:

Only 22% of the health expenditure is public funded in India as compared to 44% in the US, or 95% in countries like Sweden or 75% in all the market economies of the world taken together.”

And then Uncle Sam tells us:

ccc1

 

 

“But there are lots and lots of problems with this simple solution: What are the popular causes for dissatisfaction against doctors and the delivery of health care in India today?

We have now half a dozen very cynical doctors, grimacing…

ddd1

 

“These causes are leading to an increasing alienation of the community from the Medical profession, which is a very unhealthy trend.” 

 

“Yesterday, all my troubles seemed so far away…” warbled the Beatles. Little did they know they were singing about Indian healthcare delivery systems.

My family doctor as a child was very much a friend of the family. Much more than a friend really, he was treated as a demi-god…The medicine was dispensed in little paper twists, and seemed to be a mixture of some or all of half a dozen powders for any illness…

 

eee1
The corporate hospital below is architecturally unappealing, but the point gets made: a drain for money…(don’t miss the security guard). Quickfix hospital indeed.

fff1

 

Ah, the problems of the GP…but he bears them manfully, he is most preferred after all.

aaa1

 

The breakeven analysis, a French phrase for something unmentionable…guess I’m incurably foulmouthed. Let us pray to the gods that be that nothing ever breaks even, perish the thought!

ggg1

 

The book goes on to say:

 

“A corporate hospital is run like an industry! It is run to maximize returns on investment. The number of people who need investigation will invariably be less than that needed to break even – especially as more and more hospitals will open. Where there is a high return of investment in any sector in a market economy, more units of that type develop. However this will not push down costs or promote efficiency. It will rather promote more unnecessary investigations, unnecessary hospitalization, unnecessary surgeries and unnecessary referrals. Some of these are done as malpractice. But a greater trend is to shape modern medical science so that there is more and more “need” for investigations, hospitalization and surgery. For any other commodity if there is competition the price will stabilize around its value. But since no value is too high for human life, the ability to price is limitless. It is limited only by the ability of the consumer to pay.”

 

Strong words. I would, by and large, disagree. Let me tackle it point by point, and present my viewpoint on the rhetoric above.

 

An exclamation mark after industry indeed! “Maximize returns on investment”, do I need to wash my mouth out with soap again? What was wrong with the Indian mantra after Independence? Among other things, it set up a huge, inefficient public sector (including public healthcare) to which it denied autonomy of working; there were low to no “returns on investment” (excuse all this obscenity) and we had a poor capital-output ratio. It also pampered organized labor to the point where productivity became extremely low. All the rulers of our country did was institutionalize democracy, in the name of the poor. Indian socialism ended up doing very little for the poor. Ideology is not the solution, better management and more especially incentives to manage better, are.

 

A high return on investment in healthcare? To succeed in the 21st century, healthcare providers need to respond to the looming threat of competition and capitation. “…will not push down costs?” The impending advent of insurance and health maintenance organizations will usher in managed care. Where policy-led reform failed, market-led reform may succeed. The driving force in healthcare is going to be an economic message of managing care, managing cost, and managing clinical efficiency to create a sustainable healthcare delivery system for India. For us who are marketing design services, we can already see a shift in the customer. The customer in the past has been the hospital. More recently it is becoming the medical group and tomorrow’s customer will be the health network or even a HMO.

 

“Some of these are done as malpractice. But a greater trend is to shape modern medical science so that there is more and more “need” for investigations, hospitalization and surgery.” Sir, madam, the second is more than mere “malpractice”, it is paranoia on your part and megalomania on the part of the modern medical scientists engaged in this endeavor, if any are so involved. Both are pathological conditions and call for therapy.

 

“But since no value is too high for human life, the ability to price is limitless. It is limited only by the ability of the consumer to pay.”  “Rhetoric” is defined by my Webster’s College Dictionary as ‘language skillfully used’. It goes on to also define it as the ‘undue use of exaggerated language; bombast.’ I submit that along with the evils of globalization we have also been given to learn the skills of shopping. A fool and his/her money will always part ways soon. We do not debate the actions of fools. Corporate hospitals target the well-to-do as customers; they got that way by being savvy about money matters. They pay for quality.

 

The economic risk of providing comprehensive services to a potentially large and eventually enrolled population will have to be managed by clinical integration and disease management. This is the reengineering of patient care. The design opportunity in this is not simply to make reengineered care clinically efficient, but to focus on the patient care experience and on the processes of achieving greater efficiency through improved engineering and facility design. The mantra is patient-focused care, not about providing spectacles by charging separately for the frame and each of the lenses.

 

As the kids nowadays say, “get real…”

 

Money Talks – AC/DC
Dr Sunil Pandya: Commercialisation of Medicine

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

947 thoughts on “Confronting Commercialization of Healthcare

  • Reply
    Leroy Berlin
    Most useful human beings toasts should amuse and present give about the couple. Beginner audio systems previous to obnoxious throngs would be wise to remember often the valuable signal using grow to be, which is to be an individual’s home. finest man speech examples
  • Reply
    Draftkings
    Thank you for the auspicious writeup. It if truth be told was once a leisure account it. Look complex to far delivered agreeable from you! By the way, how can we be in contact?
  • Reply
    Gabriella Arai
    Can I say thats a relief to discover somebody who really knows what theyre speaking about online. You definitely learn how to bring a concern to light and make it critical. Lots more people ought to read this and see why side from the story. I cant believe youre not more popular when you absolutely provide the gift.
  • Reply
    Doria Chiang
    Can I say thats a relief to find a person that truly knows what theyre discussing online. You actually discover how to bring a challenge to light and make it important. The best way to ought to check this out and can see this side of your story. I cant believe youre no more well-known because you absolutely provide the gift.
  • Reply
    business
    Wow! This could be one particular of the most helpful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Actually Fantastic. I am also an expert in this topic therefore I can understand your hard work.
  • Reply
    game development
    We are a group of volunteers and opening a new scheme in our community. Your web site offered us with valuable information to work on. You've done a formidable job and our whole community will be grateful to you.
  • Reply
    dzialki budowlane
    Thanks for the article. oduytscc My partner and i have always observed that a majority of people are desirous to lose weight when they wish to show up slim along with attractive. However, they do not always realize that there are additional benefits just for losing weight in addition. Doctors declare that fat people come across a variety of ailments that can be perfectely attributed to their particular excess weight. Thankfully that people who sadly are overweight and also suffering from several diseases can help to eliminate the severity of their own illnesses by means of losing weight. It is easy to see a progressive but noted improvement with health whenever even a minor amount of weight reduction is achieved.
  • Reply
    Bula Cotelesse
    I keep listening to the news broadcast lecture about receiving boundless online grant applications so I have been looking around for the most excellent site to get one. Could you advise me please, where could i find some?
  • Reply
    Freda Fisk
    The particular Amish’s important faith centered idea of Demut “humility”, plainly demonstrates the particular weak spot related to individualism as well as sociable school therefore well-known concerning individuals civilizations and also there exists a matching sturdiness relating to Amish party id.
  • Reply
    www.probirka.org
    I would like to take the opportunity of saying thanks to you for your professional advice I have often enjoyed viewing your site. I will be looking forward to the actual commencement of my school research and the entire planning would never have been complete without consulting this site. If I could be of any assistance to others, I would be pleased to help through what I have gained from here.
  • Reply
    Sherlyn Wilcinski
    healthcarearchitecture.in is solid, well-researched content. I just now forwarded this on 11/19/2016 to a coworker who's been involved in some work of his own on the topic. To show his appreciation, she just bought me a drink! So, I should probably say: Thanks for the drink!
  • Reply
    zobacz tutaj
    A further issue is ujhfcsahg that video games are normally serious anyway with the main focus on mastering rather than leisure. Although, we have an entertainment factor to keep your sons or daughters engaged, each one game is usually designed to develop a specific skill set or area, such as math concepts or technology. Thanks for your write-up.
  • Reply
    Bryan Gapinski
    Thanks for this outstanding article. 1 other thing is that a lot of digital cameras come equipped with the zoom lens that enables far more or less of your scene to get included by means of ‘zooming’ in and out. All these changes in concentration length are usually reflected although in the viewfinder and on significant display screen proper at the back with the specific camera.
  • Reply
    Lorean Rishor
    After study a few of the content on your own website now, and i also truly as if your strategy for blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark site list and you will be checking back soon. Pls look into my internet site as well and told me what you think.
  • Reply
    Ray Cody
    Thank you for making the trustworthy effort to talk about this. I think very sturdy approximately it and would like to read more. If it’s OK, as you gain more extensive wisdom, would you thoughts adding extra articles very similar to this one with additional info? It could be extraordinarily useful and useful for me and my friends.
  • Reply
    wiecej info
    One more important hufhshshd issue is that if you are a senior citizen, travel insurance with regard to pensioners is something you must really take into account. The mature you are, the greater at risk you will be for permitting something negative happen to you while in foreign countries. If you are not necessarily covered by several comprehensive insurance policies, you could have some serious challenges. Thanks for giving your ideas on this weblog.
  • Reply
    simply click the up coming website
    I have had Firefox, IE, and Google chrome downloaded onto my computer for a while now with no problem. Recently I downloaded YIM and now Firefox doesn't start up. If I restart my computer a few times, and try to open it a few dozen times each time I restart, it will eventually pop up. How do I fix it? Chrome and IE still work fine but I prefer Firefox..
  • Reply
    Lucien Raddle
    Many thanks for being the mentor on this niche. We enjoyed the article greatly and most of all appreciated how you really handled the issues I regarded as being controversial. You are always very kind towards readers really like me and assist me to in my life. Thank you. Palm Beach Gardens
  • Reply
    Armand Ingebretsen
    There are undoubtedly lots of particulars like that to take into consideration. That could be a good level to deliver up. I offer the thoughts above as basic inspiration however clearly you can find questions just like the one you bring up the spot the most important thing shall be working in sincere good faith. I don?t know if finest practices have emerged around issues like that, nonetheless I'm positive that your job is clearly recognized as a excellent game. Both girls and boys genuinely feel the affect of just a second’s pleasure, for the remainder of their lives.
  • Reply
    Food Pyramid
    I precisely wished to say thanks again. I'm not certain the things I would've tried in the absence of the entire methods revealed by you directly on my situation. It was a real frightful crisis in my view, however , observing your specialized way you managed the issue made me to cry over fulfillment. Now i am thankful for the assistance and in addition pray you realize what a great job that you're carrying out teaching some other people thru your web blog. More than likely you haven't come across any of us.
  • Reply
    Dating
    If you're still upon the fence: grab your favourite earphones, intellect down in the direction of a Simplest Buy and question in the direction of plug them into a Zune then an iPod and look at which just one appears far better towards your self, and which interface helps make by yourself smile much more. Then you may know which is instantly for on your own.
  • Reply
    Small Business Internet Marketing
    Good ¡V I should definitely pronounce, impressed with your web site. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs and related info ended up being truly easy to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it in the least. Reasonably unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, web site theme . a tones way for your customer to communicate. Excellent task..
  • Reply
    Nathanial Skuse
    Woah! I’m actually loving the template/theme of this weblog. It’s simple, but effective. A great deal of times it is difficult to get that “perfect balance” between user friendliness and visual appeal. I need to say you've done a wonderful job with this. Also, the weblog loads super quick for me on Opera. Excellent Weblog!